Automatic Rough


As a student pilot, it amazed me how many nooks and crannies there were on the training airplanes I flew, plus the number of openings, doors, covers and access panels. I don’t know what I was expecting, but the fact all this is designed to be opened up for inspection and put back together took some getting used to.

As I progressed through training, certification, an instrument rating and, finally, ownership of a previously owned Beech A36 Bonanza, I got used to it. I even helped my A&P-IA with the annual inspection a few times. That just exposed me to even more nooks, crannies and access panels, of course. I made it a habit to closely inspect them after any maintenance was performed and during my preflight preparations.

The A36 has one access panel the Cessnas I used to fly didn’t: a hinged door under the left wing, covering the fuel drain at the bottom of the cockpit-mounted fuel selector. It has one of those quarter-turn fasteners with a funny-shaped flat portion that allows the pilot to twist it to lock the fastener in place and keep the door closed. Sumping the fuel-selector’s drain and checking the airplane for open panels and doors is one of the last things I do during preflight before climbing aboard.

And that’s what I did on the flight I’m writing about. Taxi, run-up and takeoff were normal, and soon I was climbing out of Grand Rapids, Michigan, on my way to Madison, Wisconsin, for a business meeting. Yes, across Lake Michigan. It was summer, and I had flotation devices aboard. I’d made the trip before, climbed up to 10,000 feet each time I crossed and knew that there was only a few minutes of the flight where I was out of gliding distance to land.

As I leveled off at altitude and let the A36 accelerate, I noticed an unusual noise. I considered turning back, but was pretty much halfway to the Wisconsin shoreline, so I continued. Once settled into cruise, the noise seemed louder, but all the aircraft gauges reported normalcy.

Nearing Madison, I started to descend, and the noise got louder. I debated telling Air Traffic Control and requesting priority handling, but I didn’t know how to describe the problem. I soon landed uneventfully, taxied to parking and shut down. Before unloading, I walked around the airplane and…there it was. The small door covering the fuel selector drain was hanging open. I don’t know if I missed it on the preflight, or if it opened on its own. I later had my A&P mechanic replace the fastener, to prevent it from happening again.

Learning Experiences

Have you encountered a situation or hazardous condition that yielded lessons on how to better manage the risks involved in flying? Do you have an experience to share with Aviation Safety’s readers about an occasion that taught you something significant about ways to conduct safer flight operations? If so, we want to hear about it.

We encourage you to submit a brief (500 words) write-up of your Learning Experience to Aviation Safety for possible publication. Each month, Aviation Safety publishes a collection of similar experiences sent to us by readers. Sharing with others the benefit of your experience and the lessons you learned can be an invaluable aid to other pilots.

You can send your account directly to the editor by e-mailing it to [email protected]. Put “Learning Experience Submission” in the subject line; add your name and daytime telephone number at the bottom of the e-mail.

Your report will be considered for publication in the Aviation Safety’s readers’ forum, “Learning Experiences,” and may be edited for style and length. Anonymity is guaranteed if you want it. No one but Aviation Safety’s editor is permitted access to the reports. Your name and telephone number are requested only so that the editor can contact you, if necessary.

While we can’t guarantee your submission will get published, we can guarantee that we’ll closely review and consider using it.

All Learning Experience submissions become the property of Aviation Safety and may be republished.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here